Menu of Dairy Supreme in Edinboro, Pennsylvania, USA

Menu Overview

Located in Edinboro, PA, Dairy Supreme stands out as a quintessential ice cream shop that blends classic comfort food with delightful frozen treats. The moment you step into their cozy space at 104 E Plum St, you are welcomed by a menu that balances savory and sweet offerings with thoughtful pricing. Their specialty lies not just in ice cream but also in hearty sandwiches and unique bar options, creating a well-rounded dining experience.

Their Flurries are a must-try for anyone seeking rich, creamy indulgence with a twist. Flavors like Turtle, Mint Oreo, and Chocolate Chip offer a perfect balance of texture and taste, combining smooth ice cream with crunchy and flavorful mix-ins. The Flurry’s consistency is just right—not too dense, yet rich enough to satisfy.

For those in the mood for something more substantial, the Hot Dog, Fries, and Small Drink combo priced at $4.95 offers excellent value. The menu’s spotlight on sandwiches such as the Chicken Breast Sandwich ($6.70) and the intriguingly named Hippie Special provide options for various palates. The sandwiches are well-constructed, fresh, and pair wonderfully with their classic side fries.

The savory options extend to unique items like the Ox Roast ($5.45) and the K.m.r. & On., Chili, Cheese & Kraut, which speak to a regional flair and hearty flavors. The use of kraut and chili in combinations for hot dogs and sandwiches, such as the Wilson Jr. Chili, Cheese, H.p., & On. & Tom, highlights the brand’s commitment to bold, satisfying tastes layered with tradition.

The Parfaits, including the Hot Fudge Parfait at $5.80, offer a lighter yet indulgent option that showcases their ice cream’s quality through layers of rich fudge, fresh whipped cream, and crunchy toppings. They strike a balance between dessert and refreshment that feels both nostalgic and indulgent.

Overall, Dairy Supreme presents a menu that is both accessible and thoughtfully curated. It is a place where premium ice cream treats coexist seamlessly with hearty, flavorful dishes rooted in local tastes. Whether you’re craving a cooling Flurry or a savory sandwich with all the fixings, Dairy Supreme delivers with authenticity and care. The blend of classic and inventive offerings makes it a standout destination for anyone seeking comfort food and quality ice cream in Edinboro.